comments 10

You’re Never Too Young to Trust Your Gut (Lessons Learned from Making a Terrible Decision)

tuenight do over amy barr
tuenight do over amy barr

Amy, around age 18. (Photo courtesy of Amy Barr)

If only we could soften the pain of regret by revisiting the source of our angst. If that were so, I’d have gotten over this particular wound decades ago as I’ve thought about my decision at least a thousand times. It seemed so complicated at the time, but the lesson learned — the lesson that stays with me nearly 40 years later — is simple: When something feels wrong, it probably is.

At age 17, my life was unraveling. My mother was dying, and my father was undone by the seemingly endless slog of her illness. He did his best to take care of my brother and me, and, in terms of creature comforts, we were fine. But crushed as he was, my father could offer no emotional or logistical support about the decisions I faced as I contemplated college. There were no discussions of which schools might suit me and no campus tours. Whatever research was to be done, I was on my own.

I was a good student, and my options were undoubtedly greater than I thought, but I cast a narrow net, applying to only two places: Barnard College in New York City (about 15 miles from my suburban home) and a large state school several hours north, which was only on my radar because a neighbor went there. On the day of my Barnard interview, I loved the feel of the compact campus, the mix of old red bricks and modern glass walls. I soaked up the energy of upper Broadway and the quirky girls whizzing around. Yes, this could be right.

A few days later, I got the nod — I was in! It was a sliver of light in the darkest of skies, but there was one huge hitch: Due to overcrowding in the dorms, incoming students residing within 25 miles of campus had to live at home and commute to school.

This was definitely not what I had in mind, but my mother objected even more. She wanted me to have a real college experience. To her, that meant living with a gaggle of roommates on campus, not taking a subway alone to the George Washington Bridge and then a smelly bus down Route 4 every night, arriving home to see how much more life had ebbed from her eyes since I’d left that morning. She encouraged me to head upstate instead, thinking if she were out of my sight I’d somehow become a happy college coed.

Every part of me felt that leaving was wrong, yet, after weeks of discussion, my mother wore me down. I reluctantly said no to Barnard and yes to a sprawling public university I’d never laid eyes on until the day I moved into my dorm.

[pullquote]I sat on the edge of her bed stroking her hand, chanting the word “Hi” over and over. I had so much I wanted to say, but that’s all that would come out.[/pullquote]

I hated it instantly. The buildings were squat and charmless, as were most of the boys. I zombied my way through classes and missed home desperately. I smoked pot in an effort to dull my ache, but, instead of giggling, I sat in silence most of the time. The highlight of my days was the cafeteria’s butterscotch pudding, which I downed three at a clip.

The error I’d made in choosing this place over Barnard was all too apparent, but my larger mistake was the one that consumed me: I’d let my mother send me away during the final months of her life. She thought it was best, but it was the opposite of what was best. I wanted every minute I could have with her, yet here I was, nearly 200 miles away, as lonely for her as she likely was for me. The irony was that we made this awful choice to make each other happy.

During my third month in exile, two days before Thanksgiving, my father called to say I needed to get home. I’ll always be grateful to some guy named Jeff with his little yellow Pontiac who drove five hours through a blinding snowstorm to drop me at Mount Sinai Hospital before he headed home to Long Island. Upstairs, my mother had already slipped into a coma. I sat on the edge of her bed stroking her hand, chanting the word “Hi” over and over. I had so much I wanted to say, but that’s all that would come out.

My mother died on Thanksgiving Day. A month later, I went upstate to retrieve my belongings and left that campus for good. I should’ve – or somebody should’ve – called Barnard and begged them to take me in, but I was too fragile to do much but bounce in and out of a string of schools for the next couple of years. I regret that deeply. Perhaps it’s silly to think I’d be different or my life would’ve have been richer had I chosen Barnard all those years ago. I’ve accomplished a lot, yet it nags me to this day.

The funny thing is it wasn’t until I sat down to contemplate the subject of what I’d do over if I could that I realized my regret over Barnard isn’t the real regret at all. The real regret is that I didn’t say to my mother, “I’m staying here. That’s what’s best for me.” If I’d stayed home, maybe we would’ve talked about what was happening to her – and to me. Maybe I would have had the chance to say a real goodbye instead of repeating that mindless “Hi.”

I know this story is mine alone, but the takeaway is for everyone — especially young people who might not yet have the guts to trust their gut. To them, I say beware of what feels wrong and respect what feels right, even if that means contradicting someone you love who thinks they know what’s best for you.

Filed under: Loss


Amy Barr

Amy Barr is a veteran magazine editor. She started her career as an editorial assistant at Working Mother magazine and rose through the ranks to become Executive Editor before joining Time Inc. to launch the online edition of Parenting, where she served as managing editor. Amy was also part of the online launch teams for Worth.com, What to Expect When You're Expecting, The South Beach Diet and Everyday Health. You can find Amy on Twitter at @amylbarr.


  1. Sandy (Metzger) Honeyman says

    Amy, I had no idea what you were coping with back in those days – wish I had. Hope you know that your mother would be so proud of where you are now and that you said all you needed to in the years you had together. Beautiful essay.

    • Amy Barr
      amy barr says

      Thanks, Sandy. I was pretty quiet about it back in high school, just wanting to be normal. I really appreciate you taking the time to comment.

  2. Cynthia says

    Thank you so much for sharing this Amy. I lost my mom near Easter my Junior year at Barnard. Even though she was 2000 miles away we probably spent more time together than since I’d lived at home. My regrets today are just wishing she could have met my wife and daughter.

    That year at Barnard my mom let me know she was proud of the woman I was becoming surrounded by challenging and exciting professors and classmates. My most peaceful times that year were babysitting for a sweet baby boy named Nicholas and his lovely mother Amy. You both were a grounding force during my time of loss which I appreciate to this day.
    Thank you.

    Cindy the Barnard babysitter
    P.S. My gut was right . New Mexico was a great choice. I go by Cynthia or Alex’s mom these days. 😉

  3. Susan Shuwall says

    Dear Amy: That is an extraordinary essay you have written. Losing a Mother at that age must
    have been horrendous. It is unfortunate that your Mother did not live to see what a courageous
    daughter you were and how accomplished a writer you are now! Your expressions of feelings
    are so REAL and bring the reader right to the moment of that time. Sending you love and
    congratulations! Susan

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *