Letters TueNight Amy Barr

Note Never Sent: To the Mother Whose Son Assaulted Mine

(Photo: Courtesy Amy Barr)

On a rainy Friday night not so long ago, my son Nick was assaulted by a fellow student in a bar near the college they both attended. They were strangers at the time. It seems that in a drunken state, the young man mistook Nick for someone else, someone who triggered an outburst of violence. The incident lasted about three seconds. No words were exchanged and only one punch was thrown, but it was enough to put my son in the hospital with a concussion and a broken eye socket.

That weekend was awful. Nick looked terrible and felt worse. But just as disturbing as the worry and pain associated with the assault were the events that followed, which sent our family reeling.

We were profoundly disappointed by the school’s disciplinary process, which let the assailant off the hook and left Nick feeling victimized all over again. It also taught us some harsh lessons about justice.

As for me, I went from feeling anxious to being outraged, not only at the University but also at the kid who sucker-punched Nick. I was angry with his parents, too, especially his mother. I wanted to pinch this boy’s ear for being a thug and pinch his mother’s for raising one. I became fixated on the conversation I might have with her if I ever got the chance. I even looked up her address and fantasized about knocking on her door to say my piece. Eventually, I wrote her this letter and in the process, discovered some unsettling things about who I am as a parent and as a citizen of the world. Turns out, she and I may be more alike than I thought.

I never mailed this letter, but I share it here for all mothers to consider.

Dear Mrs. L.,

We’ve never met but we are now forever linked, at least in my mind, by the fact that your son assaulted mine. Nick has recovered. The surgery to fix his lower orbital bone was successful, his eyesight has returned to normal and, save for a small scar on his cheek where his eyeglasses cut into his skin, he’s fine. But I’m not.

I can’t stop thinking had that punch landed at a different angle or had my son hit his head more forcefully as he fell to the floor, he could be dead. I can’t stop thinking your son walked away from this experience with neither a physical nor emotional scratch. And I can’t stop thinking that you helped him do that.

You and your husband hired the lawyer who coached your son to say Nick pushed him first. Though I wasn’t present, I imagine you breathed a sigh of relief when that lie became a successful “my word against yours” defense. And I imagine you hugged your son when the school gave him a slap on the wrist, and allowed him to resume his studies, his social life and his status as an offensive lineman on the football team.

Perhaps worst of all, I can’t stop thinking that I would’ve done the same.

I, too, would have protected my child from the consequences he deserved. And in the process, I would have taught him the same warped lessons that you have imparted to yours: That lying is an acceptable method of saving one’s skin; that money can make trouble disappear; and that personal responsibility is a choice, not an obligation.

Does that make us bad parents? Honestly, I’m not sure. I do know it makes us mothers first and citizens second. Yes, one of our jobs – an important one to be sure – is to teach our children right from wrong and to nurture honesty and kindness. But our first job, our instinctive job, is to protect them. I couldn’t protect my child when your inebriated son slugged him out of the blue, but I understand why you protected your son in that hearing room. This offense wasn’t life changing for anyone involved but the situation makes me think about mothers of children whose crimes are much worse. I imagine most of them feel the same protective urge that you and I do, to shield our children from suffering and shame, even in light of the bad things they’ve done.

Attitudes such as yours and mine contribute to the divide between those with the means to escape punishment and those without. We perpetuate a sense of superiority and entitlement as we foster a sense of detachment from our fellow man. By our acts, we exhibit compassion for our own children but we teach them to avoid feeling it for someone else. I feel terrible about this. But I don’t see how to reconcile my motivation as a mother with my duty as a human being. Do you?

The truth is I’ve got no moral high ground to stand on since I would’ve acted as you did. I can fantasize that one of us (you) is bad and the other (I) is good, but that’s nowhere near true. My sense of morality – and apparently yours – is much more fluid, capable of running like rushing water around an obstacle in its path. 

That’s why I understand that you couldn’t pay my son’s medical bills. To do so would have meant acknowledging your son’s culpability and your complicity. But I wonder if you think about what happened, as I so often do, in the middle of the night and feel awful about what you felt you had to do. I imagine you do. And in my dreams, one day you’ll call to tell me so, as one troubled mother to another.


Amy Barr

Tell Us in the Comments

What do you think?

7 Responses

  1. Dear So-and-So | Tue Night

    […] Amy Barr stopped herself from sending one. […]

  2. Tessa

    One possibility not mentioned above is that the other mother believed her son. As you believed yours. That is quite different from being willing to lie on his behalf.

    • Amy Barr
      amy barr

      You are absolutely right. Strangely enough, that possibility never occurred to me nor did the possibility that it was my son who was lying. There might be a whole other essay in there. Thanks for making me think about that.

  3. Firenza Cole

    Dear Amy,

    That’s great that you’re being so reasonable. If only more people were like you, instead of erroneously believing in their own goodness and others’ badness. Your thoughtful essay also made me think of consequences. In this incident, the assailant didn’t mean to cause your son such a serious injitry (or at least, I assume.) He even assaulted the wrong person. But had Nick hit the floor at a different angle, as you suggested, that boy might be in jail for murder or manslaughter. Conversely, if the punch hadn’t inflicted such damage, the boy would never have had to see a lawyer or be in trouble with the university. This proves that it’s not our acts or intentions, but the uncontrollable consequences that determine our lives , our criminal status, and how we’re seen by society.

    As I’ve just written an ebook on the subject of lying, your post struck a chord with me. I’ve met so many black-and-white thinkers over the years. Once again, I’m ompressed with your reasoning here.

    All the best,


  4. Adrianna

    I don’t know — one kid ended up punched, the other did not. It doesn’t matter what the argument was or who lied, the medical bills should have been shared by both sides.

  5. Tom

    It’s the height of empathy for you to put yourself in that mother’s place — but as you said, she helped her son do that. You helped your son be someone who would never do that — and so you never would, or could, actually be in that mother’s place.

    • Amy Barr
      amy barr

      I think you’re right about how we help build our children’s character. My son is far from perfect but I feel confident he would never assault another person, especially without provocation. When this occurred he declined to try to prosecute or sue the other young man, telling me that wasn’t the experience he wanted to remember about college. He didn’t want that to define his time there. I was disappointed with that decision at the time but ultimately, it also speaks to the person he is and to the success of our efforts to raise a thoughtful person. Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.